There’s no scarcity of copies after Michelangelo on supply in Outdated Grasp auctions, however the “Follower of Michelangelo” in Dorotheum’s sale in Vienna appeared totally different. For a begin, it was huge, over 2.5m excessive, and made up of a number of bits of paper. It seemed to be a cartoon, a preparatory work for transferring a design onto a frescoed floor. It was rubbed in elements, however vigorous and assured. It was additionally part-painted, with massive, daring strokes. “Tempera”, mentioned {the catalogue}. Michelangelo painted in tempera. Certainly it couldn’t be…
I zoomed in additional. The big, bearded determine resting his head on his hand was the prophet Jeremiah from the Sistine Chapel ceiling. He seems to be gloomily downwards, supposedly mourning the autumn of Jerusalem, however the sitter has lengthy been recognised as a self-portrait and is claimed to mirror Michelangelo’s despondency at being pressured to color the ceiling. And intriguingly, there have been variations between Jeremiah within the drawing and within the ceiling; his left hand was positioned extra to the suitable, his shoulders had been in a distinct place, as was his gaze, even his ft. Why would a copyist do that?
No giant preparatory drawings from the Sistine Chapel survive. However I discovered that 4 cartone had been found in a trunk after Michelangelo died. One was described as a single, life-size male determine. Now I used to be actually getting excited. Was the Dorotheum drawing the one recorded in Michelangelo’s property? A self-portrait, which is probably why Michelangelo determined to maintain it? And did I’ve the prospect to purchase it for simply €6,000?
I booked a flight to Vienna. I advised my spouse why, and made a case for betting the farm (truly, her farm) on the sleeper of a lifetime. The Dorotheum is one among my favorite public sale homes, and I used to be glad to have an excuse to go to. The attractive rooms make it the very best place on this planet for displaying Outdated Grasp work on the market. Every little thing seems to be good, even copies. After I received there, the drawing was hung excessive up, and I needed to make do with a glimpse of Jeremiah’s ft. I do know hardly something about Outdated Grasp drawings, however I believed they had been good ft.
I got here house and carried on researching. The British Museum has one of many 4 cartone saved by Michelangelo, referred to as The Epifania. The cartoon used to belong to Thomas Lawrence, a major collector of Michelangelo drawings, who purchased instantly from Michelangelo’s heirs. Trying into Lawrence’s assortment, I discovered that he had a full-sized copy, in oil, of the Jeremiah by an artist referred to as William Bewick. After which, to my astonishment, I discovered a picture of Bewick’s copy on-line, and noticed that it replicated virtually precisely the Dorotheum drawing, together with within the methods it differed from Michelangelo’s Jeremiah within the completed Sistine ceiling.
For a couple of minute I believed I may need cracked it. Did Lawrence personal the unique drawing, and had it been copied by Bewick? Might I hint the drawing within the Dorotheum all the best way again to Michelangelo’s heirs, and was it the one listed within the artist’s stock?
After all not. It seems Lawrence despatched Bewick to Rome in 1826 to repeat the Sistine Chapel ceiling. Bewick’s letters reveal how he received permission to erect a scaffold and started to make his copies in oil, till at some point the Pope complained concerning the odor of paint. So Bewick determined to make cartoons in Michelangelo’s fashion, utilizing a number of bits of paper, with odourless tempera. And it was his cartoon now at Dorotheum. The fantasy was over. It offered for €25,000—and to not me.
