What ENS just proved about every crypto DAO

does decentralized governance in DAOs really work? this is an almost existential-level question on the realities of one of crypto’s most core toolings, and it’s being put to the test by what’s happening with the Ethereum Name Service DAO lately.

if you’ve heard buzz around the drama surrounding ENS lately but couldn’t be bothered to keep up, I explain!

but broadly:

a Temp Check hit the ENS forum last week proposing to move operations, grants, and treasury management out of constant token votes and into a five-seat professional board at the ENS Foundation, with one seat reserved for founder Nick Johnson. token holders keep protocol control and the power to remove directors, and the Foundation can't vote its own treasury tokens.

two onchain moves landed around the same time: Johnson self-delegated close to half of all active voting power in ENS governance, and a brand-new wallet with no public identity received ~200k ENS traced back to ENS Labs, instantly becoming the second-largest delegate.

Lefteris Karapetsas (rotki) says it looks like coordinated preparation to swing the vote. Katherine Wu, the proposal's lead author, says a board with teeth is professionalization, and a founder holding his tokens is exactly what we ask founders to do.

every DAO eventually hits this wall. full-token voting is slow and exhausting, but the moment someone tries to fix it is also the moment concentrated voting power matters most.

i put together a ~4 minute breakdown covering the proposal, the wallet trail, and posing the ultimate question: when a decentralized community needs to change how it makes decisions, who gets to decide what that change looks like when all else has seemingly failed?

super curious to hear this subreddit's thoughts on DAO governance! what are the successful examples? is ENS bound to be an example of a failure in decentralized governance? or is what ENS is doing necessary for the growth of the protocol?

——————————–

if we're meeting for the first time — hi 👋 i built this channel to spread the good word on good work in crypto. a like, a comment, and a sub on my channel goes a long way to supporting my work 🙂